Bristol Clean Air Zone – two years on, what is the future of the CAZ?
Professor Graham Parkhurst (Centre for Transport & Society) & Professor Jo Barnes (Air Quality Management Resource Centre)
We are ‘penning’ this piece almost exactly two years after Bristol City Council’s Clean Air Zone came into force, on 28 November 2022. The ‘CAZ’, as it is known, was needed along with other measures to achieve the minimum standards of air quality required by UK law, the most important of which is defined in technical terms as an annual mean concentration of Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) not exceeding 40 µg/m3. Due to the extent of pollution in Bristol, the CAZ covers most of the busy historic centre of the city, but the exact boundary and rules also reflect consultation with local businesses and communities and needed central government approval. Bristol’s CAZ charges older, more polluting petrol and diesel vehicles. Unlike some other cities with a CAZ, such as Bath, Bristol’s includes private cars. In practice, most of the private cars affected are diesel cars first registered before 2016.
So, two years on, has the CAZ worked, and what is its future?
It’s fair to say that CAZs across the UK are an emergency measure. Had action come sooner it is possible it could have been less drastic. The vehicle pollution problem had been known about for years. The standards were meant to have been met in January 2010 (and local objectives by December 2005!). But successive governments overly relied on improvements in vehicle technology to solve the problem. Events like the ‘dieselgate’ scandal showed this approach was far too optimistic. Still, it took an environmental pressure group, ClientEarth, which won a High Court case against the government, to force decisive action.
The High Court ruling resulted in a ‘direction’ from national government instructing local authorities to reduce NO2 “in the shortest time possible”. Bristol was one of the local authorities across England directed by the government’s Joint Air Quality Unit (JAQU) to create a CAZ for this purpose in 2017, although local political agreement for a CAZ in Bristol had already been reached through a full council motion a year earlier.
Although the CAZ is now two years old, it takes time to process the air quality and traffic data collected across the city. We do know from a summary report published by the council after the first year of operation that reductions in NO2 were found both inside and outside the CAZ boundary (9.7% on average across the whole city; 12.8% decrease within the zone and a 7.8% decrease outside of the zone). But travel was still recovering from the COVID-19 pandemic, so it was hard to be sure how far the reductions reflected the CAZ, or the reduced travel. There are indications, though, that when the second-year assessment report is published it will show an even larger decrease in pollution, with traffic for 2023 back to 95% of pre-COVID levels. With more working from home apparently being a permanent behavioural change resulting from the pandemic, this level of traffic may represent the ‘new normal’.
Despite this good news, the need for the CAZ is ongoing. There are still particular locations which do not meet the required standard. And achieving them just once is not enough. Due to variations in weather and traffic, JAQU requires local authorities to demonstrate compliance with the limits for three years before the CAZ is seen to have fully worked. Also, some vehicle owners with non-compliant vehicles will currently be choosing not to use them in the CAZ, due to the daily fee. If the CAZ is removed too soon then those more polluting vehicles might come back, pushing pollution levels up again.
The CAZ doesn’t remove all air pollution. It simply addresses the areas of cities with the worst problems, and only for NO2. Arguably, tougher standards, affecting a wider range of vehicles (and pollutants), should be considered. But over the longer term, there will be fewer and fewer internal combustion engine vehicles on British roads as they are gradually replaced by electric vehicles. The government’s Zero Emissions Mandate has rising annual targets. More than half the cars sold by each manufacturer in 2028 must have no exhaust emissions at all, which in practice means they must be purely electric. This is good for reducing air pollution, but electric cars still need road and parking space and result in congestion and road danger. In eventually moving beyond the era of the CAZ, do we want to build on the principle that car use needs to be managed in the wider public interest? Or is the individual right to drive more important?
Related news
04 December 2024
UWE Bristol to lead £1.3 million project to evaluate the use of phone app to help with back pain
UWE Bristol will lead a £1.3 million project to evaluate the effectiveness of using an NHS-recommended smart phone app to help people suffering with low back pain.
02 December 2024
Project led by UWE Bristol launches new resources to tackle racism and discrimination in healthcare education
A range of inclusive training and learning resources to tackle racism and discriminatory behaviour in healthcare have been launched by UWE Bristol.
28 November 2024
Work of UWE Bristol academics features in Government report on air quality measurement
Two UWE Bristol academics have made contributions to an influential Government report on the measurement of air pollution.
27 November 2024
Traffic noise reduces the stress-relieving benefits of listening to nature, study finds
Road traffic noise reduces the wellbeing benefits associated with spending time listening to nature, researchers have discovered.
15 November 2024
Global body confidence education project supported by UWE Bristol reaches 20 year milestone
A global initiative supported by UWE Bristol to build body confidence and self-esteem for the next generation of young people has celebrated its 20th anniversary.
22 October 2024
‘Life changing’ prosthetic leg developed at UWE Bristol to be trialled at global competition
Researchers from UWE Bristol are preparing to showcase an advanced bio-inspired prosthetic leg they have developed to improve the quality of life for people with above-knee amputations.
15 October 2024
Researchers create 3D printed food for people with swallowing difficulties
Researchers have developed meals suitable for people with dysphagia (swallowing difficulties) using 3D printing technology.
10 October 2024
UWE Bristol graduates release song for Bristol-based Talk Club on World Mental Health Day
Through a university-led scheme, UWE Bristol graduates have created a music single aimed at raising awareness of national mental health charity Talk Club.
08 October 2024
Robotic clothing to aid walking a step closer after £11m funding
A new hub will develop healthcare technologies to support the independence of older people with in-home, on-body physical assistance devices.
01 October 2024
Research study aims to improve dementia assessments for diverse communities in Bristol
UWE Bristol is launching a research project aimed at transforming the assessment and diagnosis of dementia for people from three minority ethnic communities in Bristol.
01 October 2024
New guidance launched to help local authorities promote health through Local Plans
New practical guidance to help local authorities in England create places that promote health has been co-authored by a UWE Bristol academic.
29 August 2024
Public trust in drinking water safety is low globally, study finds
A new study has found more than half of adults surveyed worldwide expect to be seriously harmed by their water within the next two years.