1. Topic

  Residential emissions modelling

2. Introduction

   

Emissions related to residential buildings heating are an important pressure for the urban air quality. The amount of pollution due to these kinds of emissions is very different for different cities because of different climatology, different fuels employed, different wind patterns and so on. Anyway, as a general rule, they should not be neglected in order to achieve reasonable air quality assessment. Residential emissions are usually treated as 2-dimensionally distributed and, in the CORINAIR approach, emission factors for residential combustion plants are estimated exactly as the corresponding industrial emissions, when similar equipment is used (boilers, gas turbines and so on). On the contrary, in the case of equipment such as stoves or fireplaces, residential emissions should be treated separately from industrial ones.

3. Discussion

   

Share of residential emissions in urban areas

Residential emissions derive mainly from domestic heating and their share in European urban areas strongly depend on local climate, with longer and higher emissions in cold northern or mountain towns and shorter heating periods with less intensive fuel combustion in Mediterranean cities.

As an example, residential emissions for the city of Milano (Italy) account for the 60% of annual SO2, 10% of NOx and 13% of PM10 urban emissions (2001 INEMAR Emission Inventory).

Total emissions are estimated with the same methods used for assessing industrial emissions, as similar devices are involved but, obviously, domestic emissions follow seasonal and daily cycle different from industrial ones.

In certain cases local administrators decide the period in the year and the hours of the day when buildings are heated, whereas in other cases citizens are free to manage heating on their own.

Residential emissions in air quality modelling

When dealing with air quality modelling, residential emissions are usually considered as area emissions distributed accordingly to the urban density.

If no other information is available, emission height could be estimated equal to the average building height. Depending on the scale of the simulation, it could be useful to distinguish between at least town centre, residential zones and suburbs assigning different emission heights, especially when dealing with large cities.

The main problem of residential emissions modelling is the high aggregation level of data used to calculate air pollution. In Italy databases of firewood (ISTAT) and oil fuel (Oil Bulletin of Ministry of Industry) consumption is available with year-nation resolution and rarely year-region and year-province. Moreover, methane market liberalization makes difficult locating of distribution companies (ITALGAS, SNAM, etc.) on territory. Data are never at urban scale. Temporal disaggregation is still more difficult because autonomous heating doesn’t obey old law 373 (1976). In fact, this imposed heating lighting timetable per regional zones. Now these data sets are not available.

To disaggregate data to urban scale these proxy variables can be used:

  • Population;
  • Buildings volume heated;
  • Buildings thermal requirement.

Typical data source for these proxies is ten-yearly ISTAT census.

Approximate thermal requirement can also be so assessed: volume heated x building dispersion parameter x day mean temperature. More complex treatment, with decreasing of heat dispersion during heating plant stop phase due to internal temperature decreasing, needs knowledge of building thermal capacity.

Finally, to disaggregate annual data the following proxy variables can be used:

  • Monthly proxy: to be calculated as difference between inside (for example 20°) and outside (monthly mean) temperature and multiplied for number of work days. Then to be normalized to 1.
  • Weekly proxy: for residential heating a uniform proxy variable is used; for tertiary, it is appropriated to look for specific weekly profiles, because activity diversification is enormous (offices, shops, hospitals, etc).
  • Daily proxy: to be calculated based on mean hourly difference between inside and outside temperature and multiplied by 0 when there is no work, by 1,1 or more when heating plant starts to work (bigger consumption) by 1 in other hours. Then to be normalized to 1.

Autonomous heating specific questions adding to ISTAT census could be an economic and effective solution.

Emissions and energy saving

Building energy efficiency is a major concern, as pointed in the “EcoBuilding” Directive 2002/91/CE, and Member States are encouraged to act in order to minimize heat and energy waste in residential buildings.

According to the Directive, for new buildings with floor area larger than 1000 m2 and for buildings that undergo a major renovation, the feasibility of alternative and more efficient heating systems should be considered.

More efficient heating systems are, for example, decentralised energy supply systems district or block heating or cooling or heat pumps.

Furthermore, the same Directive states that residential boilers fired by non-renewable liquid or solid fuel of an effective rated output of 20 kW to 100 kW have to be inspected on a regular basis whereas boilers of an effective rated output of more than 100 kW shall be inspected at least every two years.

This continuous maintenance of boilers imposed by the directive is expected to improve domestic heating emissions and is likely that emission factors will undergo an important revision.

Wood burning

Wood burning is a popular method for domestic heating, especially in northern countries. According to the CORINAIR Guidebook the contribution of wood burning to total emissions is thought to be insignificant (i.e. < 1%). Nevertheless, recently a number of studies have been published showing that emission factors for PM2.5 from wood burning are strongly dependent on technology employed and that emissions from conventional stoves and manually fed boilers are often one or two orders of magnitude higher than emissions from newly designed boilers and stoves. Other studies are underway and extensive revision and updating of emission factors is expected in future years.

4. Recommendation / Conclusion

   

Check estimates

The recommendations contained in the topic Assessing emissions from industrial facilities, Venice + ENEA - ,ESA Contribution of checking, when possible, theoretical industrial emissions computed on the basis of CORINAIR emission factor with real measures applies also to domestic emissions.

Pay attention to urban evolution

Renovated and new buildings are likely to ameliorate their emission budget; boiler inspection could lead to substitution of older devices with more efficient ones; buildings change destination from commercial to residential or vice-versa. In a few words, urban areas changes continuously and residential emissions change accordingly. For air quality management and modelling it is crucial that inventories should catch these changes in order to update their emission estimates on a regular basis.

5. Examples / Further Reading

   

A specific example Background and domestic sources in Bristol was provided by Bristol.

6. Additional Documents / Web Links

   

· CORINAIR Emission Inventory Guidebook (3rd edition): http://reports.eea.eu.int/EMEPCORINAIR3/en.

· EcoBuilding Directive 2002/91/EC.

· Johansson et al. Emission characteristics of modern and old-type residential boilers fired with wood logs and wood pellets, Atm. Env. 38, 4183-4195.

· Illerup et al. Particulate matter emissions and abatement options in residential wood burning in the Nordic countries, in Proceedings of the PM Emission Inventories Scientific Workshop, Pallanza, 18/10/2004.

EC

Last Updated


 

25th January 2005

Back